Friday, January 20, 2012


As readers and writers of science fiction, we are more familiar than most with the double-edged sword of technology. Every bright, shiny new toy casts a dark shadow, because humans invented it and, most of all, humans play with it.

So, we love our instant access to information through the Internet, the answers to every question at our fingertips through Wikipedia and Google, the chance to connect with friends and family through Facebook, to catch up on missed episodes of our favorite shows through Hulu or Ooooh, shiny!

But to all of this there is a dark side: websites like, for example, that steal content from legitimate copyright owners—authors like you and me, moviemakers, television producers, musicians—copy it and make it available to others for a fee without paying anything to the people whose sweat went into creating that content. U.S. prosecutors just shut down the site and arrested four of megaupload’s criminal masterminds in New Zealand, charging them with copyright infringement, racketeering and conspiracy to commit money laundering. According to news reports, several of megaupload’s “sister” sites were also involved in distribution of child pornography and terrorism videos.

The organization behind megaupload is said to have defrauded copyright holders of some $500 million in legitimate earnings. It is only one of hundreds of such sites stealing from content producers every day—every minute—on the Internet. Prosecutors have limited weapons with which to fight them. (Note that megaupload was charged with old-school racketeering, and only because they used U.S.-based servers for some of their work.)

Those of you lucky enough to have published books online have almost no recourse at all against piracy of your work. Anyone, anytime can take a downloaded file, upload it to a “file-sharing” site, and your work is available free to anyone else who wants it. Of course, copyright law prevents such a thing, BUT THERE ARE NO SANCTIONS FOR ANYONE WHO DOES IT. You can spend hours out of every day chasing these thieves down and “asking” them to remove your work from their sites. They may or may not do it, depending on how they feel. All those hours of blood, sweat and tears that it took you to produce your work, and you get nothing for it.

That’s why many of us in the publishing world greeted introduction of legislation in Congress to put a stop to online piracy with hope. The Stop Online Piracy Act in the House of Representatives and the Protect IP Act in the Senate were the first attempts to craft some sort of response to the rampant rip-offs taking place all over the Internet. Much of the media attention to the bills focused on the threat of piracy to the movie and music industries, and, indeed, the bills had the support of the Motion Picture Association and the smaller Creative America nonprofit association of industry workers.

But the legislation was just as important to those of us who hope to gain from the revolution represented by digital publishing. Without some sort of real handle on piracy, epublishing—either by an online house or self-publishing—will never be truly equivalent to traditional publishing. After all, there is little danger that some burglar will pull up to a warehouse and steal 20 percent of your inventory of paperbacks before they are sold. Or hit your publisher’s accountant in the head and take 30 percent of your earnings. But there is every possibility that an online thief will upload your book and take a huge chunk of your potential earnings from you. And the better your book is, the more potential there is for theft.

Our hope for some help from this legislation was short-lived, however. Howls of “censorship!” from some of the cyber-industries' biggest dogs put an instant stop to the efforts of Congress to do something about online piracy. Google and Wikipedia led the way with protests last week, but most online big names chimed in, claiming SOPA and PIPA would clap the Internet in the irons of censorship. Really? I had no idea Google and Wikipedia relied so much on pirated information. Maybe, naively, I thought most of what I was reading (and using) was uploaded with permission by the authors themselves. Maybe I’ll go back to using the freakin’ library.

Or maybe the people who run Google and Wikipedia could take a look at this problem and become part of the solution. If SOPA and PIPA go too far, as they say, then they should take a hand in crafting new legislation that gets rid of the bad guys, while preserving aspects of information sharing that are legitimately useful. (I still know how to use a card catalog, but—do they even still have card catalogs?)

Because we have to get rid of the bad guys. Congress has now canceled its vote on the bills, SOPA has been withdrawn, but Congressional leaders still seem open to examining the issue. With everyone working on it, perhaps we can come up with something sensible.

As the parent of any toddler knows, too much freedom is just as bad as none at all. And as I believe Thomas Hobbes once said, a life without a social contract is “nasty, brutish and short”. Living on the dark side is no way to live.

Information for this posting drawn from an article by Eric Engleman and Laura Litvan,

Donna’s Journal

What can I say? It’s January, it’s cold and dark, and progress is slow. This quote says it all:

Write even when you don’t want to, don’t much like what you are writing, and aren’t writing particularly well.
--Agatha Christie

Cheers, Donna


  1. You perfectly captured the two-edged sword (perfect image BTW) that is SOPA.

    I'm firmly against digital piracy. Even though I don't have anything available yet to steal, so many of my peers have lost hundreds if not thousands of dollars to the multitude of piracy sites.

    Authors make so little as it is, it really hurts to see potential earnings stolen away by predators who didn't put in the time, effort, blood, sweat, and tears to create a marketable novel, but have no qualms at all about taking it illegally and distributing it for free.

    They believe they are entitled. I've really come to dislike that word and the whole attitude that goes with it. No one is entitled to anything that is result of someone else's efforts.

    Many believe they aren't hurting a thing. Maybe they are just poor struggling students, minimum wage workers or those on fixed incomes thinking they can't possibly be impacting a rich author who lives on a yacht by downloading just one little copy for themselves for free.

    That couldn't be further from the truth. The cheapening of intellectual properties means that these thieves are literally taking meals right off the table for many of these struggling authors.

    That said, I believe in protecting authors, but I can't endorse a bill that will essentially lock down the internet to seekers of information. SOPA had good intentions, but like so many things in the political arena, it went overboard and evolved into a frightening monster that threatened so many facets of our lives.

    I believe the only way to cure the piracy ill is to develop affordable software that ensures a digital story CAN'T be uploaded or shared after it's purchased and initially downloaded.

    Laws don't--and won't--stop piracy. Only making piracy next-to-impossible is going to fix this travesty.

  2. I'm on the fence with SOPA - I've seen the arguments for and against and there are great points on both sides. The bottom line for me - is that Google sits there with all these illegal file sharing sites offering copies of my books, and won't do anything about it. I am expected to follow up each sighting, send notices, - that most often get ignored - and tackle the whole thing myself. Google WILL act on some stuff and I do get that they don't want to stifle freedom to post but profiting from or letting others profit from illegal activities is wrong.


Comments set on moderation - all spammers will be exterminated!

About Spacefreighters Lounge

Hosted by 5 Science Fiction Romance authors with 8 RWA Golden Heart finals and a RITA final between them. We aim to entertain with spirited commentary on the past, present, and future of SFR, hot topics, and our take on Science Fiction and SFR books, television, movies and culture.